What Is Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS)? A Comprehensive Guide for Investors

In 2024, the volume of mortgage-backed securities issuance in the United States amounted to approximately $1.6 trillion, underscoring the continued importance and scale of this market within the financial ecosystem.

The federal government has played a pivotal role in supporting the mortgage market and the development of mortgage-backed securities through institutions like the FHA, Fannie Mae, Ginnie Mae, and Freddie Mac.

But what does this mean for you as an investor or stakeholder in the housing market? How do these complex financial instruments influence the availability of mortgage credit, the stability of the housing market, and your portfolio’s risk and return profile? Understanding mortgage-backed securities is not just for Wall Street professionals; it’s essential for anyone navigating today’s financial landscape.

The scale and importance of MBS highlight their significance within the broader securities industry, where they represent a major asset class and influence capital flows. This guide will walk you through the essentials, providing clarity on the mechanics, types, risks, and economic impact of mortgage-backed securities.

What is Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS)?

Mortgage-backed securities are financial instruments created by pooling together residential mortgage loans into a mortgage pool and selling shares of the resulting cash flows (principal and interest payments) to investors. The mortgage pool generates a stream of cash flow for investors, which is fundamental to the structure and evaluation of these securities. In a pass-through MBS, the issuer collects monthly payments from a pool of mortgages and passes on a proportionate share of the collected principal and interest to bondholders.

At its core, an MBS transforms individual home loans into a tradable asset, allowing investors to receive regular payments derived from homeowners’ monthly payments. These monthly payments consist of both interest and principal payments, which together make up the cash flow distributed to investors.

This process not only supports liquidity in the mortgage market but also links your investment returns directly to the health of the residential housing market and borrower behavior.

How Do Mortgage-Backed Securities Work?

Mortgage-backed securities originate when mortgage lenders, such as banks or mortgage companies, securitize mortgages by bundling a pool of loans into a single security. Investors then buy shares of this pool, essentially lending money to homebuyers, as their investment provides the funds that support the underlying mortgages.

The monthly mortgage payments (comprising principal and interest) flow through to investors, typically on a monthly basis, creating a steady income stream. A loan servicer is responsible for collecting these payments from borrowers and distributing them to investors.

Key Players and Market Dynamics

Government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs, or government-sponsored enterprises) like Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the Government National Mortgage Association (Ginnie Mae) play pivotal roles. Agency mortgage backed securities, issued or guaranteed by these entities, typically offer lower credit risk due to government backing and are considered core bond holdings in diversified investment portfolios.

Ginnie Mae, in particular, guarantees that investors receive timely payments on securities backed by federally insured mortgages, including FHA-insured mortgages, further reducing default risk and maintaining investor confidence.

The legal structure of the issuing entity (whether a government-sponsored enterprise or a private issuer) significantly impacts the risk profile and guarantees of the mortgage-backed security, influencing factors such as credit risk, liquidity, and payment timing.

Conversely, private financial institutions issue non-agency MBS, which carry higher credit risk but often offer higher yields.

Types of Mortgage-Backed Securities

• Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities (RMBS): Backed by pools of residential mortgages, these are the most common MBS types. Most mortgage-backed securities are structured as pass-through securities, which allocate cash flows, including principal payments and interest, directly to investors. The weighted average coupon of the mortgage pool is an essential metric for investors, as it influences prepayment risk and yield.
• Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities (CMBS): Backed by commercial property loans, such as office buildings or shopping centers.
• Agency MBS: Issued by GSEs and generally carry implicit or explicit government backing. These often include pools of fixed-rate mortgages, which pay a fixed interest rate, providing predictable cash flows and influencing refinancing and prepayment behavior.
• Non-Agency MBS: Issued by private entities without government guarantees.
• Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (CMOs): A type of collateralized mortgage obligation, these complex MBS repackage principal payments and manage mortgage prepayments by dividing cash flows into tranches, offering different risk and maturity profiles.
• Stripped Mortgage-Backed Securities (SMBS): Separate principal and interest payments into distinct securities.

Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (CMOs): A Closer Look

What Are CMOs?

Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (CMOs) are a sophisticated type of mortgage-backed security that have become a cornerstone of the modern mortgage market. Unlike traditional mortgage-backed securities, which pass principal and interest payments directly to investors, CMOs divide the cash flows from underlying mortgage pools into distinct tranches.

The key difference between traditional mortgage pass-throughs and CMOs is in the principal payment process, with CMOs offering prioritized repayment to different classes of investors. These are repackaged pass-through mortgage-backed securities with cash flows prioritized.

Structure and Risk Profiles

Each tranche is designed with its own risk and return profile, allowing investors to select the levels of prepayment and interest rate risk that best match their investment strategy.

Key issuers of CMOs include the Government National Mortgage Association (Ginnie Mae) and the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae). These government-sponsored enterprises play a pivotal role in the CMO market, providing stability and confidence for investors by guaranteeing timely payments on many of these backed securities.

The structure of a CMO means that the earliest tranches receive principal repayments first, which can help reduce default risk for those investors, while later tranches may offer higher yields in exchange for taking on more risk.

Benefits and Challenges

Benefits

• CMOs are engineered to provide a steady stream of principal and interest payments, making them attractive to investors seeking predictable cash flows.
• They offer the ability to tailor investments by selecting tranches with risk and return profiles that match specific investment goals.
• This structure can help manage prepayment and interest rate risks more effectively than traditional mortgage-backed securities.

securities.

Challenges

However, CMOs are not without challenges:

• When interest rates fall, homeowners are more likely to refinance their mortgage loans, leading to prepayment risk.
• This can result in principal being returned to investors sooner than expected, potentially reducing the yield if reinvestment opportunities are less favorable.
• Conversely, when interest rates rise, prepayments slow.
• The average life of the CMO may extend, exposing investors to interest rate risk.

Market Innovations and Support

Over time, the CMO market has evolved to address these risks. Innovations such as floating-rate tranches help investors manage exposure to changing market interest rates, while credit enhancements like over-collateralization and subordination are used to reduce credit risk.

The Federal Reserve Bank has also supported the CMO market by providing liquidity, especially during periods of market stress, ensuring that investors can buy and sell these mortgage-backed securities efficiently.

Risks to Consider

Despite these safeguards, CMOs still carry certain risks:

• Credit risk remains a concern, particularly for tranches backed by lower-quality mortgage loans, but can be mitigated through credit enhancements and careful structuring.
• Liquidity risk is another factor, as some CMOs may be harder to trade, especially in volatile markets.

By understanding the structure and risk profile of different CMO tranches, investors can better align their investments with their risk tolerance and income needs, making CMOs a versatile tool within the broader universe of mortgage-backed securities.

The Role of the Federal Reserve in the MBS Market

Monetary Policy and Interest Rates

The Federal Reserve is a central force in the mortgage-backed securities (MBS) market, shaping its direction and stability through a range of powerful tools. One of the most significant ways the Federal Reserve influences the MBS market is through its monetary policy decisions.

By adjusting interest rates, the Federal Reserve can directly impact the cost and availability of mortgage loans, which in turn affects the demand for mortgage-backed securities.

Lower interest rates typically make borrowing more attractive, fueling home purchases and increasing the volume of mortgage loans that can be securitized.

Quantitative Easing and Market Support

During periods of economic uncertainty or financial crisis, the Federal Reserve has taken even more direct action by purchasing large quantities of mortgage-backed securities as part of its quantitative easing programs. These purchases inject liquidity into the MBS market, support the housing market, and help stabilize the prices of backed securities.

By acting as a major buyer, the Federal Reserve can reduce credit risk and ensure that financial institutions have the confidence and capital needed to continue issuing new mortgage loans.

Regulatory Oversight

Beyond its role as a market participant, the Federal Reserve also regulates and supervises the financial institutions that originate, issue, and trade mortgage-backed securities. This oversight helps maintain the soundness of the financial system, ensuring that banks and other institutions manage their risks appropriately and treat mortgage borrowers fairly.

The Federal Reserve’s guidance is especially important for maintaining investor confidence and supporting the smooth functioning of the MBS market.

Coordination with Other Agencies

The Federal Reserve’s involvement in the MBS market is a balancing act. While its actions can support the housing market and promote economic growth, they must also be carefully calibrated to avoid creating excess risk or instability in the financial system.

The Federal Reserve works closely with other regulatory agencies, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Department of Housing and Urban Development, to ensure that the MBS market operates transparently and efficiently.

The Federal Reserve’s Impact

In summary, the Federal Reserve’s influence on the mortgage-backed securities market is profound. Through its control of interest rates, direct market interventions, and regulatory oversight, the Federal Reserve helps shape the environment in which mortgage-backed securities are issued, traded, and valued.

Its actions not only affect the MBS market and housing market, but also have far-reaching implications for economic growth, financial stability, and the availability of credit for millions of Americans.

Risks Associated with Mortgage-Backed Securities

Understanding the risks is crucial for managing your exposure:

• Prepayment Risk: When homeowners refinance or pay off mortgages early, investors receive principal repayment sooner than expected, which can reduce income if interest rates fall and reinvestment opportunities are less attractive.
• Interest Rate Risk: Rising interest rates can decrease MBS prices as fewer homeowners refinance, extending the average life of the securities and potentially lowering returns.
• Credit Risk: Particularly relevant for non-agency MBS, where borrower defaults can lead to losses. Mortgage defaults can be especially problematic during economic downturns, resulting in significant losses for investors.
• Liquidity Risk: Liquidity risk varies significantly across different types of mortgage-backed securities, with agency MBS generally being more liquid than private-label MBS. Some MBS, especially non-agency or complex tranches, may be less liquid, making buying or selling more challenging.

Unlike mortgage-backed securities, which are backed by pools of home loans, other types of asset-backed securities (ABS) are collateralized by assets such as auto loans or credit card receivables, each carrying its own unique risk profile.

During the 2007-2008 financial crisis, subprime loans and subprime mortgages (high-risk loans made to borrowers with poor credit) were bundled into mortgage-backed securities. The widespread defaults on these subprime mortgages led to massive losses for investors and played a central role in the collapse of the housing market and the broader economic downturn.

The Economic Impact of Mortgage-Backed Securities

MBS play a vital role beyond individual investments. By securitizing mortgages, lenders can replenish capital to originate new loans, supporting homeownership and the broader residential housing market. The presence of MBS in the mortgage market encourages lenders to originate more loans due to reduced risk, as these securities provide a mechanism for transferring risk to investors.

Investment banks are central to this process, as they structure, aggregate, and issue mortgage-backed securities to the market. Institutional investors, such as pension funds and insurance companies, are major buyers of MBS, providing significant liquidity and stability to the market.

According to data from the Financial Markets Association (SIFMA), the size and growth of the MBS market are closely tracked, highlighting its importance within the broader financial system. The average daily trading volume in the MBS market is almost $300 billion, reflecting its liquidity and central role in the financial ecosystem. This process helps stabilize mortgage rates and fosters economic growth.

However, as the subprime mortgage crisis demonstrated, misaligned incentives and lax underwriting can amplify systemic risks. Regulatory reforms and enhanced transparency aim to mitigate these risks and enhance market stability.

Investing in Mortgage-Backed Securities: Considerations and Strategies

If you’re contemplating MBS investments, consider:

• Your risk tolerance, investment horizon, and income needs.
• The type of MBS (agency versus non-agency) and the associated credit quality.
• Interest rate outlook and potential prepayment behaviors.
• Investment vehicles, including direct purchases, mutual funds, or ETFs specializing in MBS and other asset backed securities.

Mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are a type of fixed income security, but unlike traditional fixed income securities such as corporate or government bonds, MBS carry unique features like prepayment risk and variable cash flows.

In contrast, most fixed income securities offer fixed interest payments and predictable maturity structures. Asset backed securities, including MBS, auto loan-backed, and credit card receivable-backed securities, can be accessed through mutual funds and ETFs, providing diversified exposure to these instruments.

Professional advice can help tailor strategies that align with your financial goals.

Conclusion: Navigating the MBS Landscape with Insight

Mortgage-backed securities remain foundational to the financial system, serving as a critical link between the housing market and global capital flows. Their diverse structures (from agency MBS with implicit government backing to complex collateralized mortgage obligations) offer investors various risk and return profiles tailored to different investment goals.

The MBS market has grown due to rising demand, global economic growth, and monetary policy efforts, further solidifying its role in the global financial landscape.

Understanding the interplay of key factors such as prepayment risk, interest rate risk, credit risk, and liquidity risk is essential for making informed investment decisions. Moreover, the role of government-sponsored enterprises like Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae, along with the Federal Reserve’s market interventions, provide important stability and confidence in the MBS market.

As interest rates fluctuate and borrower behavior evolves, staying informed about these dynamics will help investors balance income potential with risk management. Whether you are a conservative investor seeking steady income through agency MBS or a more risk-tolerant investor exploring non-agency or structured securities, mortgage-backed securities offer opportunities to diversify fixed income portfolios while supporting the broader housing market and economic growth.

By maintaining awareness of regulatory changes, market trends, and the underlying mortgage pool characteristics, you can effectively navigate the complexities of MBS investing and leverage these instruments to meet your financial objectives.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What are the main benefits of investing in mortgage-backed securities?

Mortgage-backed securities offer relatively stable monthly income streams, diversification from traditional bonds, and often higher yields compared to government bonds. They provide monthly payouts, which can offer a steadier income for investors than bonds, which typically offer a lump-sum payout at maturity.

Agency MBS provides added safety through government guarantees, making them attractive for conservative investors.

How do interest rate changes affect mortgage-backed securities?

When interest rates fall, homeowners tend to refinance, leading to prepayment risk that can reduce future income for MBS investors. Conversely, rising interest rates may extend the life of MBS, exposing investors to price declines but potentially higher yields over time.

What is the difference between agency and non-agency MBS?

Agency MBS are issued or guaranteed by government-sponsored enterprises and typically carry lower credit risk. Non-agency MBS are issued by private institutions without government backing, thus carrying higher credit and default risk but potentially offering higher returns.

Can mortgage-backed securities impact mortgage rates for borrowers?

Yes. By providing liquidity to lenders through securitization, MBS help lower the cost of capital, which can translate into more competitive mortgage rates for borrowers, supporting homeownership and economic growth.

How can I invest in mortgage-backed securities?

You can invest directly by purchasing MBS through brokers or indirectly through mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that specialize in mortgage-backed securities. Understanding the specific risks and structures involved is essential before investing.